Quick Answer: Is Five Star Tax Resolution Legit?
Yes. Five Star Tax Resolution is a legitimate, BBB-accredited (A+) tax relief firm founded in 2007 and headquartered in Pasadena, California, serving all 50 states. They put licensed tax attorneys, CPAs, and IRS Enrolled Agents on your case, require a minimum of $10,000 in tax debt, and offer a money-back guarantee if they can’t resolve your case. The trade-offs: premium pricing (fees start around $3,500 and average about $7,500 per Forbes) and a small third-party review footprint compared to bigger competitors.
When readers ask me about tax relief companies, I look for the same basics every time: who is actually doing the work? What services do they offer? How much do they charge? What are their reviews and ratings? Five Star Tax Resolution is a firm in the “tax problem solving” space, and my goal here is to explain how to evaluate them, what to expect from the process, and the questions I would ask before signing anything. Tax debt sits in its own corner of the debt relief world, with different rules, different negotiators, and different scams to avoid.
Is tax debt your only problem — or part of a bigger one?
If credit cards, personal loans, or medical bills are piling up alongside your IRS balance, a tax firm alone won’t fix it. Take our 60-second quiz to see which type of debt relief actually fits your full situation.
Company Snapshot
| Official Name | Five Star Tax Resolution Inc. |
| Headquarters | Pasadena, California |
| Founded | 2007 |
| Service Area | All 50 states |
| Minimum Tax Debt | $10,000 |
| Fees | Flat fee by phase; reported starting around $3,500, average ~$7,500 (Forbes) |
| Guarantee | Full refund if they can’t resolve your case (per their BBB profile) |
| Team Credentials | Tax attorneys, CPAs, IRS Enrolled Agents; NATP, NAEA, CTEC affiliations |
Legitimacy, Ratings & Reviews
Five Star Tax Resolution is a legitimate, BBB-accredited firm. Their consultations are free, they quote binding flat-rate fees, and unusually for this industry, they back the work with a money-back guarantee. Here is where their third-party ratings stand:
| Platform | Rating | Review Count |
|---|---|---|
| BBB (A+ Accredited) | ~4.76/5 | Small base |
| TrustPilot | ~4.0–4.4/5 | ~23 reviews |
| Accreditations | BBB, NATP; team certs from NAEA and CTEC | |
My honest read: the ratings are good, but the review footprint is tiny for a firm operating since 2007. Compare that to a company like Tax Relief Advocates, which carries thousands of reviews across BBB and Google. A small review base isn’t disqualifying, but it means each individual review tells you less, and it makes the free consultation and written engagement letter more important, not less. One industry reviewer also noted the firm works with a reputation management company, which may partly explain the scarcity of negative feedback online. Take the star averages with a grain of salt and judge them on the specifics they put in writing for your case.
What Five Star Tax Resolution Does
Like other popular tax resolution firms (such as Tax Relief Advocates who you probably hear continuously on radio ads), the core menu typically includes:
🛡️ Protection & Relief
Wage garnishment releases, bank levy releases, and revenue officer assistance when collections are already active.
📋 Compliance Cleanup
Filing or amending missing returns — the IRS won’t negotiate anything until you’re current.
💰 Payment Solutions
Installment agreements, Currently Not Collectible status for genuine hardship, and Offers in Compromise when you qualify.
⚖️ Representation
Penalty abatement requests, audit defense, and payroll tax problem representation before the IRS.
The real differentiator is not the list. It is the quality of the people doing the work and how they communicate with you from week to week.
Five Star Tax Resolution VS Your Other Options
Let’s compare some of the most popular options when it comes to dealing with high tax debt:
| Feature | Five Star Tax Resolution Pro Service |
DIY with IRS Lowest Cost |
Local CPA / EA Hands-On |
Big National Firm High Volume |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who handles your case | Named EA/CPA/attorney as lead; dedicated case manager | You handle calls, forms, deadlines | Licensed practitioner; often the person you meet runs the file | Varies; large teams, work may be distributed |
| Typical services | Transcripts, filings, levy/garnishment relief, Installment Agreement, CNC, OIC, penalty abatement, audit defense | Online payment plans, amended/late filings, hardship requests, phone appeals | Same as left, plus ongoing bookkeeping/tax prep if needed | Full menu; strong at processing volume quickly |
| Estimated fees | Flat fee by phase; reported ~$3,500 to $7,500+ — premium end, backed by money-back guarantee | $0 fee to IRS for basic plans; your time is the cost | Hourly or fixed; varies by market and complexity | Wide range; can be higher for sales-driven models |
| Best for | Balances with active collections, missing returns, need for structured representation | Smaller balances, straightforward plans, comfortable self-advocates | Personalized attention, local meetings, combined tax prep + resolution | Multi-year, multi-state, high-volume processing needs |
| Pros | Dedicated licensed rep; transparent plan; money-back guarantee; secure document portal | Cheapest; fastest for simple cases; full control | Direct access to practitioner; can pair with ongoing planning/tax filing | Extended hours; deep process staff; national footprint |
| Cons | Premium pricing; small review footprint; outcome depends on your financials and compliance | Steeper learning curve; time on hold; easier to miss deadlines | Availability/pricing vary; some cases exceed a solo practice’s bandwidth | Communication can feel impersonal; sales pressure at some firms |
| Speed to action | Quick transcript pull and protection steps once onboarded; cases reportedly run 1 week to ~120 days | Depends on your time and IRS phone queues | Generally prompt, especially for local emergencies | Intake is fast; negotiations can be assembly-line style |
| Communication | Scheduled updates via portal/phone/email; single point of contact | You manage all IRS communication | Direct line to practitioner; in-person possible | Ticket-based; multiple contacts over the life of the case |
| Transparency | Written plan and flat fee by scope; clear what’s included | Full control, but you must learn the rules and forms | Usually straightforward; ask for engagement letter and deliverables | Varies by brand; ask about cancellations and refund terms |
| Bottom line | Balanced choice for guided, professional resolution without losing visibility into your case | Best if the balance is small and you’re comfortable managing forms and deadlines | Great for personalized attention and ongoing tax planning if the case fits their capacity | Useful for complex, high-volume needs; evaluate communication quality before committing |
One more comparison worth making: if your debt problem is mostly credit cards and personal loans with some tax debt mixed in, a hybrid provider may serve you better than a pure tax firm. CuraDebt is one of the few companies we’ve reviewed that handles both consumer debt settlement and tax/IRS cases under one roof, and our full ranking of debt relief companies tags each provider by type so you can see who does what at a glance.
Does a Tax Lawyer or Attorney Help?
If you are planning to work with Five Star Tax Resolution, ask exactly who will represent you in front of the IRS. A solid tax lawyer or attorney firm will center the case around licensed professionals such as:
- Enrolled Agents (EAs) who deal with the IRS every day
- CPAs with tax controversy experience
- Tax attorneys when legal complexity or litigation risk is present
I prefer firms that name the lead practitioner on my file and give me direct contact details. If you only interact with sales staff and cannot meet the EA, CPA, or attorney assigned to you, that is a yellow flag. The same logic applies if you’re weighing legal help for consumer debts — our guide to debt consolidation lawyers and attorneys uses the exact same screening criteria.
Now, on their website, it shows Victor A. Latham as the Senior Tax Attorney. Ask if you are going to receive his services if you work with them.
Victor Latham, Senior Tax Attorney.
The Process You Should Expect
- Discovery and transcripts
The firm should pull your IRS transcripts with a signed authorization, confirm balances and deadlines, and give you a written game plan. - Compliance first
The IRS will not negotiate until all required returns are filed. Expect a push to get current on filings and withholding or estimated payments. - Financial analysis
A proper analysis uses IRS Collection Financial Standards to model what you can afford. This drives your eligibility for an installment plan, hardship status, or an Offer in Compromise. - Resolution submission
The firm files the chosen path, responds to IRS notices, and handles back-and-forth until you have a written agreement or determination. - Follow-through
Good firms set reminders for future filings and estimated payments so you do not default your agreement.
Pricing and How to Think About It
Most tax resolution work is quoted as a flat fee based on complexity. Typical industry ranges for individual cases are often $2,000 to $6,000+, with payroll tax and multi-year or audit cases costing more. Five Star sits at the premium end of that range: Forbes reports their fees start around $3,500, with average cases running about $7,500 — roughly double what some leading competitors charge. The counterweights are the binding flat-rate quote, payment plans, and the money-back guarantee if they can’t resolve your case. Many firms phase the work:
- Investigation phase to pull transcripts and map options
- Resolution phase to prepare and negotiate your case
- Compliance or monitoring phase if needed
What I ask for:
- A written engagement letter with scope, deliverables, timelines, and total cost
- Clarity on refund policies and what happens if you disengage
- A list of what is not included so there are no surprises
⚠️ Red Flag: Guaranteed Offers in Compromise
Be wary of anyone — at any firm — who guarantees an Offer in Compromise or quotes a fee before pulling transcripts and doing a real financial analysis. Only the IRS decides who qualifies, and the FTC has taken enforcement action against multiple tax relief firms for deceptive claims. Before paying anyone, run your numbers through the IRS’s own free Offer in Compromise Pre-Qualifier. If a salesperson promises “pennies on the dollar” before seeing your transcripts, walk away.
Strengths I Look For With a Firm Like This
- Clear point of contact and updates on a set cadence
- Licensed staff who will be the ones speaking to the IRS
- Education first mindset with realistic expectations
- Document portal and secure ways to share sensitive files
- Written plan that matches IRS standards rather than sales talking points
Potential Drawbacks to Weigh
- Upfront cost can feel high if the balance is small or the fix is simple — and Five Star’s fees run above industry average
- Outcome uncertainty because the IRS decision depends on your true financials and compliance history
- Time to resolution can stretch for months, especially for offers or complex payroll cases
- Small review footprint means less independent evidence than bigger firms provide
✅ Five Star Might Be a Good Fit If…
- You owe a meaningful balance ($10,000+) and are facing active collections
- You have missing returns and need both filing and negotiation help
- Your situation involves payroll tax or a prior defaulted agreement
- You want a licensed professional to speak to the IRS for you — and value the money-back guarantee enough to pay premium fees
🚫 You Might Not Need a Firm If…
- You owe a small balance and can set up a standard online payment plan yourself
- You are fully compliant and simply need a short-term extension or more time to pay
- You are comfortable using the IRS’s self-service tools and calling the agency directly
Questions I Would Ask Five Star Tax Resolution
- Who will be my licensed representative and how do I reach them directly
- Can I see a written scope of work and a total flat fee by phase
- What are realistic outcomes for my case using IRS standards
- How often will you update me and through which channel
- What happens if the IRS rejects the first proposal
- What exactly triggers your money-back guarantee — and can I get the refund terms in writing
- How will you help me stay compliant so I do not default the agreement
Documents to Gather Before You Talk
- All IRS and state notices
- Last two years of filed returns and any unfiled years list
- Recent pay stubs, bank statements, and a monthly expense breakdown
- Proof of extraordinary expenses that might matter for financial standards
- Any existing installment agreements or prior IRS correspondence
Not sure a tax firm is even the right move?
Depending on your full debt picture, settlement, consolidation, counseling, or even bankruptcy may make more sense than paying a resolution firm. Our quiz compares them all honestly, in about a minute.
🔑 Key Takeaways
- Five Star Tax Resolution is legitimate: BBB A+ accredited, founded 2007, licensed attorneys/CPAs/EAs on staff, serving all 50 states.
- Premium pricing: fees reportedly start ~$3,500 and average ~$7,500 — but they offer a binding flat-rate quote and money-back guarantee.
- $10,000 minimum tax debt; consultations are free.
- Their third-party review base is small — put extra weight on the written engagement letter, not the star averages.
- If your tax debt is small and you’re compliant, try the IRS’s free self-service tools before paying any firm.
Bottom Line
Five Star Tax Resolution offers the standard suite of tax relief services, which isn’t the same as debt settlement companies who focus on credit card debt — providers like Americor or JG Wentworth explicitly do not touch IRS debt. The value you get will depend on the caliber of the licensed professional who handles your file and the firm’s willingness to set realistic expectations. If you decide to interview them, go in with transcripts, a clear picture of your finances, and the questions above. A good firm will welcome that level of preparation, give you a sober assessment, and put everything in writing.
I always recommend speaking with more than one provider and comparing fees, scope, and who will actually represent you. If your balance and case are straightforward, consider whether you can resolve it directly with the IRS. If your situation is complex or urgent, a strong practitioner can be worth the cost by protecting your rights, preventing costly mistakes, and saving you time. And if the tax bill is just one piece of a wider debt problem, our bankruptcy vs. debt relief comparison and this first-person guide on how to reduce debt in 2026 will help you see the whole board before you commit to anything.
👉 Take the Free Debt Relief Quiz 👉 Read Our Complete Debt Relief Guide
Frequently Asked Questions About Five Star Tax Resolution
Is Five Star Tax Resolution a legitimate company?
How much does Five Star Tax Resolution cost?
What is the minimum tax debt Five Star requires?
Does Five Star Tax Resolution offer a money-back guarantee?
How long does Five Star take to resolve a tax case?
Can Five Star guarantee my tax debt will be reduced?
Is Five Star Tax Resolution the same as a debt settlement company?
Can I resolve my IRS tax debt without hiring a firm?
What if I have credit card debt on top of my tax debt?
Is Five Star Tax Resolution available in my state?
Amine is an entrepreneur, investor and financial writer that covers the US economy, inflation, alternative investments, cryptocurrencies and more. He has been involved in the space for over a decade.
